Some things that some people donot know is that, Eagle,Scat, Compustar are all Chinese forgings. The difference is that they are Heat treated and machined here in the USA. I think that Callies has the best operation going as far as quality control of what's happening inside the shop. Eagle has had problems in the past with quality control IE not conforming to said measurements. Callies has a better quality control in my opinion. Scat i think is very good, in fact i have one of their 4" small b/lk cranks in my 434" motor, i also have 2 Eagles running. Now i do have issues with Scat and their customer service. As some of you know i sell parts to on the side to supplement my income (SS) (not on RJ word of mouth) i have a number of Scat flex plates SFI approved about 1/2 of them run out up to 1/4" at the ring gear. I messagened Scat about this problem over 2 weeks ago, i'm stuck with them and they will not even answer my email. It's not a lot of money but i wouldn't want to have serious problems with something like a crank or any other high dollar piece from them.
JMO
Zip.