Not going argue on this one, as it will only get the crowd riled up.
There are things I know about the eagle cranks that I can't repeat, as one of the sales men over there and I are really good friends, to where I get all my inside information.
Everybody has there opinions, and every body has there own results.
Yes eagle did have a problem with there sizing 2-3 years ago, the changed crankshaft factories. Cat is now buying the forgings that are coming out of the old eagle factory, and good luck getting one as cat never has them in stock.
Like I said, not going to argue as there is always a critic in the crowd.
Use what ever you feel comfortable with.