Ok, I will try to answer this in a non-answer.
A lot of things in automotive performance or even in life is subject to the opinions of each user. So which tire is the best? Who knows. In some classes there is one brand and one size that is heavily used and a different brand may be heavily used in others.
In the South it seems that the Mickey Thomopsons are heavier used than all others, but there are a few doing good with Hoosier, and GoodYear.
Most True 10.5 cars I see or know of are using as wide of a wheel as rules allow with beadlocks and the Mickey Thompson S sidewall tires. A few are doing the Hoosiers.
It Outlaw 10.5 W classes I.E. 11.6 wide I see a lot of the Mickeys and also some Hoosires and once in a while GoodYears.
In brackets and index racing you see just about everything but still it seems that the Mickeys are on top. M&H still gets used there too. and the Phoenix.
Street Drag Radials seems like Mickeys too, but I also see some Khumo, BFG, Hoosiers and the Good Years, Mostly it is Mickey Thompsons.
So which tire is best? Who knows.
Ed